resources for applied ethology

 

contact us

links

           

 

   

WHAT AFFECTS HORSE BEHAVIOUR?

genetics  -  gender  -  experience  -  management

 

GENETICS

 

Just as people of different ethnic origins have diverse languages, body shape, colour, stature and disparate tastes in food, so horses have sizes, shapes and behaviours that are exhibited to a greater degree in one breed than in another.  Genes, in conjunction with environmental influences, determine how our horses look and behave.  This interaction between genetics and the environment occurs naturally; it is known as natural selection and is the basis for evolution, as we shall see when we consider horse types.  The term artificial selection describes the process by which man can influence the genetic make-up of animals.  By selectively breeding for favoured bloodlines, we can speed up the process of developing different groups of horses that breed true.  These groups are the breeds. just as with people of a different nation, horses of different breeds show characteristics that are common to a family group.

 

   Type

Environmental features of a region, such as the climate and the landscape, foster the development of certain behavioural traits and conformational features which improve the survival chances of resident animals.  We can see this effect in the two recognised horse types: the so-called 'hot-blooded' horses (such as the Thoroughbred) and the 'cold-blooded' ones (such as the Clydesdale).  These terms do not actually refer to the horses' blood heat but are general labels for their body shapes, temperaments and climatic origins.  In fact, it is known that the skin can be maintained at a constant temperature even though the climatic temperature may vary.  Hot-bloods can tolerate changes in the air temperature in the range +5°C to +30° C (37°F to 86°F), while for cold-bloods the range is from -IO° C to +2 C (15°F to 68°F).

The cold-bloods developed in the cooler habitats of Europe and Northwest Asia, while the hot-bloods have their ancestral homes in hot, dry regions close to the equator.  Thus, an archetypal cold-blood is equipped with a chunky body in order to reduce heat loss, a tendency to increase body weight in times of plenty by the deposition of subcutaneous fat, and the capacity to grow a very thick winter coat.  He is the one with a phlegmatic temperament.  The hot-blood, on the other hand, is behaviourally more reactive, or flighty, in that he tends to respond to more subtle stimuli.  He has a thinner skin than his cool country cousin and his athletic physique more rapidly turns to a bag of bones when exposed to hard times.

The build of a cold-blood befits the terrain that his ancestors encountered in the wetter northern territories such as the steppes of Russia.  Having to plod through bogs and marshes demanded the strength of heavy-boned legs and muscles to match.  However, in habitats such as the semidesert, at the other end of the climatic spectrum, the long distances between water sources and areas of good grazing meant that sheer endurance was more of an aid to survival. just as the narrow tyres of a racing bike maximise performance in a velodrome while those fitted to a mountain bike are more suitable for variable terrain, the finer legs and smaller hooves found in hot-blooded horses are more efficient for sustained work on the harder ground of semidesert habitats.

The debate continues as to when the process of domestication first began for the horse, and fresh archaeological evidence is continually being uncovered to add to the discussion.  Bit wear on the molars of horse skulls that date back to 6000 BC, is thought by some to mark the first use of horses as riding animals.  However, this assumption fails to address the possibility that before that time horses were ridden in bitless bridles.  Whatever the date of the first-ever riding lesson, as herbivores with large muscle masses early domesticated horses probably first found their way into man's domain by virtue of their appeal as meat animals.  It is also possible that, rather than being simply harvested from the wild, these animals were penned up or housed.  Evidence of their having been housed dates back to 2000 BC, since skulls front this time have been shown to bear signs of crib-biting, which is thought to arise only in confined animals.

So, starting with hot- and cold-blooded types that had adapted the species to different habitats, man has selectively bred horses for a variety of behavioural traits.  Taking any indigenous type , as his raw material, he was also able to select different sizes and shapes for different kinds of work.  The Arab and the shire perfectly illustrate the diversity in the origins of the domestic horses we see today.  Both breeds have been finely selected by man, thereby grossly exaggerating conformational differences.  It is said that the Shire was initially the product of intensive breeding for a massive warhorse capable of carrying heavily armoured knights into battle, while the cultural importance of the Arabian horse in the Middle East highlights the value to Bedouins of an animal that had been bred to cope with extended journeys from one camp to another.

The numerous breeds are usually described as being either horses or ponies.  Before considering the differences between the two, it is worth emphasising that they are more or less variations on the same theme, except that there is a height limit of 14.2 hands (148 cm (58 ins) from the ground to the withers) below which an equine is referred to as a pony.  Between ponies and horses we find 'cobs', which are often regarded as combining the best features of both ends of the market.  Being over 14.2 hands but having the sturdy build that one expects in a pony, as occupants of the middle ground between horses and ponies cobs help to confirm that the distinction between the first two is largely a semantic one.  As if to highlight the fact that 14.2 hands is only, an arbitrary cut-off point, aficionados of certain breeds completely ignore the distance from the animal's withers to the ground.  Hence one never encounters such a thing as an Arab pony or a Polo horse.  Similarly, we are told that the Falabella breed is technically a horse even though it stands, on average, around 75 cm (30 ins) high.

The main differences found in ponies when we compare them with horses are to do with the body shape and metabolism that accompany being short-legged.  The equine digestive system relies on a glorified rotting process involving bugs in the large bowel.  This decomposition is called 'hind-gut fermentation'.  Because the hind-gut is so important for the breakdown of food, it is especially large in pony breeds that have had to make the most of limited resources, such as the Shetland pony which in its Scottish homeland often resorts to seaweed for nutrition.  This comparative increase in the ratio of gut volume to body size makes the pony more efficient as a digester of plant fibre; and it may be this efficiency that makes it more likely to suffer from disorders such as laminitis and hyperlipaemia when it has access to food that is too rich.  That these problems are especially common in the smallest of the ponies serves to confirm that they are directly linked to the diminutive size of these specimens of Equus Caballus (the Latin name for the domestic horse/pony/cob).

At the other end of the equine forecourt, horses have their own set of problems that are specifically linked to being tall.  For example, diseases like whistling and roaring, which involve a lack of control of the larynx, occur almost exclusively in horses and are particularly prevalent in exceptionally tall individuals.  Because disorders of the respiratory tract are so common in really tall horses, the ceiling has more or less been reached in terms of breeding the biggest horse.  Beyond 17.2 hands, wastage due to problems of this sort means that further breeding efforts are uneconomic.

Physical differences between horses and ponies rarely have repercussions when it comes to behaviour.  Even when we take into consideration their smaller frames, ponies have particularly small heads, and especially tiny ears, when compared with horses, and to the human observer this bas the effect of making a threatening grimace from a pony less dramatic than the equivalent from an aggressive Thoroughbred.  Humans are generally not very good at reading equine body language.  No doubt a horse would interpret such a gesture from a pony quite correctly, and perhaps this is why examples of domineering equine dwarfs are fairly thick on the ground.

My favourite bas to be Seamus, who was the resident Shetland pony owned by the Australian ranch on which 1 used to work.  At feeding time, all the working horses would be penned up individually and given their concentrate rations in recycled twenty-litre (5 gallon) metal containers.  But the sides of the pens were not low enough to curb the advances of the little emperor, who would march from one pen to the next pillaging food from the occupants, who were often three times his size.  As if to embellish his image, he would often have his head stuck in the feed tub from the previous pen as he moved to his next conquest - such was the intensity of his feeding frenzy.  Images of Ned Kelly, the Australian outlaw famous for his taste in metallic millinery, would spring to mind.

 

   Breed

The types of horse available to early man for domestication were products of natural selection and thus of the climate and terrain of the locality in which they evolved.  It is from these original types that man has developed the different breeds.  Thus the behaviour and conformation that we see in them are also products of the environmental conditions which moulded their ancestral types.  Naturally, through artificial selection, man enhanced certain physical and behavioural characteristics which would increase a horse's usefulness.  These are called breed-dependent characteristics.

The ability to find shelter in response to the need for it is a good example of a breed-dependent behaviour.  As representatives of a hot-blooded breed, Thoroughbreds are more likely to stand still in cold weather and look miserable, while native ponies plump for the far more sensible option of continuing their search for food or finding shelter.  Naturally, sheltering strategies involve a degree of learning - as in the New Forest foal that follows its mother under the cover of holly bushes when the rain sets in.  However, learning is just part of the story, since these animals' genes have only survived by demanding that shelter be acquired.  The genes of Thoroughbreds, on the other hand, with their more glamorous Persian origins, have not had to meet so many challenging winters and so are less well attuned to the advantages of shelter.

Similarly, in mountainous regions, the landscape has favoured the selection of animals with innate sure-footedness, and this comes with the ability to keep one's head in a crisis - which is really another way of describing an animal with a low reactivity score.  Traditionally it is maintained that the Highland pony was developed for bringing game down from the hills after a day's shooting.  Clearly, a horse that showed a tendency to tear off at speed every time a grouse broke cover from underneath his feet would not survive long in this tricky terrain.

Man can enhance Mother Nature's work by selecting genes which influence behaviours that he favours.  This means more than simply selecting quieter horses, which are predictably easier to ride.  For instance, in parts of the world where livestock are still mustered from the back of a horse, the ability to pursue an errant herd member is an extremely desirable equine behavioural trait.  And it can be bred for, along with the short back and low centre of gravity which enhance a horse's ability to turn on the proverbial sixpence and manoeuvre cattle back into or away from the herd.  The American Quarter-horse demonstrates these herding and manoeuvring traits beautifully.

Another behaviour that is breed-specific is homing ability which, while present in other breeds, is legendary in Icelandic ponies.  Why the equines of a northern island should have a refined talent for finding their way home is not clear.  A similar characteristic is a feature of Hardwick sheep, who are adept at finding their way back to their birthplace.  As a result, farmers with this ancient breed have to rely less on fencing to keep their stock in the locality.  So perhaps this same ability bas appealed through the centuries to Icelandic pony breeders.  Indeed, the idea is by no means unattractive to me whenever I weigh up the merits of being able to ride back from the pub of an evening.  Equally, having worked for a horse dealer as a child, I find the mischievous side of me speculating that this trait would be an excellent way of ensuring that you could sell the same horse many times over!  Interestingly, the behaviour of Icelandic ponies is also breed-specific when it comes to gait, since they display the amble' which is somewhere between a walk and a trot.

The development of draught animals necessitated the selection of heavy creatures that could start to shift a wagon just by leaning into the collar. 1 have great affection for these characters, but I have to say that their ability to drag things along the ground is not confined to vehicles.  Hungry carthorses have considerable pulling power, as anyone who has attempted to prevent a Sire mare from getting to her evening meal will testify.  That lady is certainly not for turning!  Heavier horses are not only the most awesome when it comes to barging but, similarly, they are notorious for leaning on the bit when being ridden.  Also called 'working on the forehand', this offers another example of how breeding can influence behaviour.

The ways in which a horse's breed affects its behaviour can even involve body language, since the tools used for sending signals can differ from one breed to another.  For instance, Arabian horses and their crosses are very demonstrative with their tails, rather like Pointer dogs are with their forepaws.  An Arabian raises his tail with tremendous frequency but, most of the time, this is simply part of his way of balancing himself when moving.  In contrast the same elevation of die tail by a Dartmoor pony would indicate a display of amazement or exuberance.

 

   Family group

Every time a horse owner decides to breed from an animal because of a particular physical or behavioural attribute, he is doing what horse breeders have done throughout the centuries.  Any horse breeder will tell you that certain family groups display certain mental characteristics.  This can influence the choice of stallion when the time comes to select a mating partner, for instance - a gentle stud will be favoured for use on a particularly talented but aggressive mare.  Temperament is known to be under genetic influence, and it follows that behavioural problems like weaving and crib-biting have also been shown to arise in individual Thoroughbred families.

Naturally, we breed from horses which have performed successfully because we know that, quite apart from selecting for good physique, we have to select bloodlines which have the temperament to excel in particular disciplines.  This sort of psychological feature can be as simple as the family's attitude to the type of work required.  For example, the dams of top police horses are likely to have been more suited to crowd control than to winning the Two Thousand Guineas.

 

For a detailed discussion of horse behaviour and simple but effective solutions to behaviour problems we recommend Why Does My Horse...?

   
back to Horse Behaviour

next section

back to top  
 

 

 Thoroughbred gelding showing the fine head typical of hot-blooded breeds

 

Clydesdale gelding showing the heavy limbs and convex profile typical of the 'cold-blooded' breeds

 © OLIVER Image Library:

contributors P. McGreevy and E. Currie

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

© Paul McGreevy

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

© Paul McGreevy

 

 

           
 

 

© animalbehaviour.net

animal animals behaviour behavior pets horse horses dog dogs cat cats animalbehavior animalbehaviour children kids problem problems behavioural behavioral learning abnormal normal Paul McGreevy